Some Questions Should be Answered By Mom

Cover of "Rules (Newbery Honor Book)"

Cover of Rules (Newbery Honor Book)

I have a 6.5 year-old daughter who is in many ways a female version of myself. The girl has black hair, dark eyes and freckles. High cheekbones give her a bit of a cherubic expression that she uses to camouflage her penchant for trouble making. She is a miniature mistress of mischief. This girl of mine is always watching the world around her and sponging it all up. This girl of mine is convinced that she can do anything that others do. I love that confidence and do all I can to build upon it. If I have anything to say about this we won’t face the self esteem issues that so many girls battle.

While I can’t guarantee that we won’t hit them I can promise to do everything in my power to help her successfully navigate the rougher waters. It is part of the job description as is handling all sorts of questions about life and the world we live in. The nice thing about her being a younger sibling is that I have already had to answer a lot of the questions. We have talked about life and death, G-d, homeless people, racism and all sorts of other tough questions. I have made a point to do try and be age appropriate with my answers. She doesn’t need to know how to build a clock, just what time it is.

However nothing prepared me for one question in particular.  It was one of those how do you make a baby type questions. It is a topic that some parents find to be challenging to discuss but not me. I figured that it was one of those things that was pretty easily handled. The kids don’t need to know all of the details, just a quick snapshot and they are good. Why mess around with something silly like a story about a stork when I can give them a basic answer that covers it all. At least that was my theory and until recently I would have stuck to it.

Except for one thing, the dark haired beauty asked me something that caught me completely off guard. She sat on my lap read me a story about Olivia (you know, the children’s book) and then looked up at me with those dark little eyes and said, “dad, how far do you stick it in?”

And then for good measure she told me that she was talking about making babies and needed to know how far the man sticks his penis in. In situations like this one of my go to lines is to turn the question back around and say, “what do you think?” Except I couldn’t do that in this case because if she had answered I might have shown up at school and beaten up all of the boys in kindergarten, first grade and perhaps the second grade for good measure. This was truly a WTF moment in the largest sense of the expression.

As the seconds stretched into months I looked at her with a blank expression and tried to figure out what I should say. If one of the boys had related this story to me I would have gleefully answered, “did you tell her all the way” or “until you hear him start snoring.” Frankly I would have preferred to have been in that position where my natural smartass nature could express itself. Instead I found myself semi-stumped and growing irritated with the stutter that had suddenly developed.

A moment later she grabbed my cheeks and told me to look in her eyes. “Daddy! I am talking to you.” That was when I realized that there wasn’t going to be a way to get out of this so I did what any other smart man would do and I punted. “Honey, that is an excellent question but I think that you mom knows more about that than I do. You should ask her.”

And with that I got up and ran for the bathroom door shouting out some sort of excuse about suddenly having developed an upset stomach.

Worth a Look:
Dad Speaks About Boys and Girls
She Is My Girl
A Six Year-old Speaks of Marriage
Rules For Dating My Daughter

(Visited 222 times, 1 visits today)


  1. Me too March 21, 2011 at 12:21 pm

    Oh, God. (shudder.)

  2. subWOW February 8, 2011 at 12:21 pm

    Oy. I cannot even imagine being caught in that situation. I am sorry; I did laugh out loud at your expense, but since I was on the train at that time, I got my just deserves from people looking at me funny.

  3. ChopperPapa February 1, 2011 at 7:57 am

    I haven’t gotten that question yet and I am totally ok with it.

  4. Cathy January 31, 2011 at 1:25 pm

    Holy cow! I wouldn’t know what to say either. Honestly, if any of my sons had that question, I think they’d ask their dad way before they’d ask me – and I think that speaks volumes to the beautiful relationship you have with your girl. I actually think my 6yo thinks babies come from your belly button.

  5. otter321 January 31, 2011 at 12:34 pm

    Oh no! That just seems too soon. Stuff like that is why I am terrified that our twins will both be girls. I am so terrified.

    • Jack January 31, 2011 at 11:08 pm

      It was actually far more innocent than it sounds. The thing is that I really had never thought about any of that in the context of talking with my daughter.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You may also like